
THE SHORT ANSWER
Pick Bumper if you will check several cars in one stretch and will end the plan the day you stop, since it renews until you cancel. Pick Carfax if service and repair entries on one particular car matter more than the price. If title brands, damage and auction records are the worry on one car, a one-time VINReportLookup report after a free preview involves no subscription at all.
- Carfax on the federal list
- Commercial customers only, California only
- Bumper on the federal list
- Public and commercial customers
- Bumper billing
- Recurring plan with a monthly report allowance
- One-time option
- Free preview, one payment, nothing renews
Carfax and Bumper side by side
Start with how each company gets paid, because that shapes the rest. By Bumper's own account, Carfax sells single reports and multi-report packs, while Bumper sells a membership with a monthly allowance of reports. The table lines up the Justice Department's list, the FTC and the companies' own pages, and marks which claims are a company's.
| Question | Carfax | Bumper |
|---|---|---|
| How you pay | By the report or in a pack, as Bumper's comparison article describes it | A recurring plan that renews until you end it |
| Federal title record for private buyers | Not sold: listed for commercial customers only, in California only | Sold: listed for public and commercial customers |
| Accident and repair entries | The FTC says Carfax may add accident and repair history | Bumper says accident records come from 44 state-level agencies, where data is digitized |
| Does the seller admit gaps? | The FTC advises an independent inspection with any report | Yes. Bumper says it cannot guarantee completeness and that you should not rely on its data alone |
Who sells the federal title record to private buyers
The Justice Department keeps a public roster of approved NMVTIS data providers, sorted into two groups. Bumper.com is filed under providers that sell to private and business customers alike, and BeenVerified.com is shown beside it. CARFAX.com is filed under business customers only, and its entry limits it to California.
A note on the same page names Carfax as one of three companies through which private buyers cannot get the federal report. The note is narrow: it concerns one government data feed, not the private records Carfax collects elsewhere. If the federal feed is what you want, Bumper can sell it to you and Carfax cannot.
Read the list on the day you buy
Providers are added and dropped. Open the Justice Department's list yourself and find both names before you pay, because that listing is what settles who may sell the federal record to a private buyer.
What the federal record holds, and what it skips
The federal record is deliberately short. The Justice Department says it covers five things: where the title stands and when it last changed, any brand the car has carried, the latest odometer figure, whether an insurer once wrote it off, and whether it passed through a salvage yard. Brands such as junk, salvage and flood count from any state, and insurers and salvage yards feed it.
Repair histories, recall information and maintenance data belong to private providers, the same government page says, and were never meant to sit in the federal record. So the two products start from different places. Bumper builds on the federal feed and lists its own accident and market sources on top. Carfax, as the FTC describes it, may carry accident and repair entries that the federal record is not designed to hold.

How Bumper bills, and where its own pages disagree
Bumper's homepage advertises a starting price of $27.99 a month. A help page on the same site lists $19.99 for each 30-day period, or $12.99 per period when you commit to three periods and pay $38.97 in total. Its billing page shows no dollar amounts and says offers change. Treat the price on the checkout screen as the only one that counts.
The help page adds the terms that decide whether a plan suits you. The plan and its report limit renew every 30 days. Billing happens when each period begins, and any reports left over expire rather than carry forward. The report page promises 50 reports a month. The homepage describes the trial as a cheaper way in for a limited time, with the standard rate applying afterward unless you cancel.
Picking by how many cars are on your list
Count the cars before you count dollars. Bumper's comparison article puts a single Carfax report near $44.99 and says packs cost less per report without printing figures. That is one company describing another, so confirm the amount on Carfax's own order page.
| Your situation | Better fit | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| One car, and dealer-style service entries matter | A single Carfax report | The FTC says Carfax may add repair history, and you pay once |
| One car, and the worry is title brands or damage | A one-time report after a free preview | Nothing renews, and you read a preview before paying |
| Several cars over a few weeks | A Bumper plan with a set end date | The monthly allowance is built for volume, but only if you cancel |
| A shortlist of three to ten cars, and no plan wanted | A bundle from VINReportLookup | One payment covers the bundle and nothing renews |
The one-time route: preview first, pay once
VINReportLookup takes a VIN and shows a free preview before any payment is asked for. If the car stays on your list, you pay once for a single report, or for a bundle sized three, five or ten if several cars are in play. Nothing here is a subscription, so no charge repeats and no plan waits to be canceled. The pricing page carries the current amounts.
A report there centers on the car's legal and damage record: whether the title carries a brand, what insurers and auctions logged after a crash, what the odometer said over the years, and whether any recall is still open. It is not a dealer service log, so a buyer who wants shop visits on one particular car should weigh Carfax for that purpose.
Reading a result from either report
Whichever report you buy, read the title lines before anything else. A report that finds nothing has told you only that nothing was recorded in the data it can see, which is why the inspection still matters.
- A salvage, junk or flood brand: the Justice Department warns the car may be unsafe, so pull the state's own title record before going further.
- A total loss or salvage entry: ask the seller for repair paperwork and photos, and have a mechanic look at the structure.
- Odometer readings that fall or stall between entries: set the dates beside the seller's account of the mileage.
- A brand in one state only: states define brands differently, so the same car can look cleaner or dirtier depending on where it was titled.
Before you pay for anything
A bare NMVTIS title record costs up to $4 per report, according to the Justice Department's buying tips, so a price far above that pays for whatever sits on top of the federal data.
- Search the free NICB database by VIN. The Justice Department's tips point to it for flood damage.
- Check recalls with NHTSA, another source those tips list.
- Read the checkout terms before entering a card: trial length, renewal amount and how to cancel. The FTC says to skip any offer whose terms you cannot find.
- If you subscribe, write the cancellation date in your calendar that day and keep a copy of the request.
- Pay a mechanic for an inspection. The FTC states that no history report substitutes for one.

Where this information comes from
- Bureau of Justice Assistance: NMVTIS approved data providers — The two provider groups, where Bumper and Carfax each appear, and the note on who cannot receive reports from Carfax.
- Bureau of Justice Assistance: Understanding an NMVTIS report — The five indicators the federal record covers and the private data it leaves to others.
- Bureau of Justice Assistance: NMVTIS used car buying tips — The upper price for a federal title record, the NICB lookup and the advice to hire a mechanic.
- FTC: Used cars — Where Carfax and others may add accident and repair history, and why no report replaces an inspection.
- FTC: Getting in and out of free trials and auto-renewals — What to read before a trial, how to cancel and how to dispute a charge that follows.
- Bumper: Common questions — Bumper's own statements on billing periods, renewal, report limits and cancellation.
- Bumper: Bumper vs Carfax comparison article — A competitor's description of Carfax pricing and service records, read as a company claim.
Sources and photos: Facts checked against the sources above in November 2026. Photos by Iain, Carrie Allen www.carrieallen.com and Dennis Eusebio on Unsplash; diagrams by VINReportLookup.
Keep reading
- Carfax alternatives: what each VIN report option covers and costsEvery option from official lookups to a one-time report, sorted by what it answers.
- How much a Carfax vehicle history report costs and what it coversWhere to read the current Carfax price and what to compare it against.
- BeenVerified VIN check cost: what the plan bills and what to compareA closer look at the brand that the federal list shows beside Bumper.
- Vehicle history report cost: what each kind charges and coversWhat each kind of report charges, from official lookups up to the premium names.
Frequently asked questions
Is Bumper cheaper than Carfax?
For a single car it can be, depending on the price you are shown. Bumper's homepage says plans start at $27.99 per month, and its own article puts a Carfax report near $44.99. The plan repeats every 30 days, though, so a forgotten cancellation turns the saving into a loss, and Bumper's pages list more than one price.
Is Bumper approved to sell NMVTIS reports?
On the Justice Department's list, Bumper.com is filed under providers that sell to private and business buyers, and BeenVerified.com appears next to it. Lists change over time, so open it and read the entry yourself before buying. The listing covers the federal title feed only, not the quality of anything else in a report.
Does Carfax sell NMVTIS reports to private buyers?
No. The same list puts CARFAX.com in the commercial-only group for California customers and says consumers cannot get the federal report through it. That limits one feed. The FTC still says Carfax may include accident and repair history.
How do I cancel a Bumper plan?
Bumper's pages list account settings, email, online chat, a contact form and a phone line, and someone signed in can pick the Cancel My Account option on the Contact Us page. A plan bought through the Apple or Google app is ended in that store, and deleting the app cancels nothing. Keep proof of the request and check your next statement.
Do I need Carfax or Bumper to check one car?
No. A one-time report from VINReportLookup follows a free preview, with no plan attached, and the three, five and ten bundles suit a shortlist. Whichever source you use, the FTC says no history report stands in for an inspection by an independent mechanic, so book that as well.
Now check the car itself
The guide explains what to look for. The report shows what this VIN has on record.