
THE SHORT ANSWER
The Justice Department names EpicVIN and VinAudit as approved NMVTIS sellers open to the public, so both can supply federal title records. VinAudit publishes its price, report layout and refund terms on pages that opened. EpicVIN's website refused every request, so its price and terms are unconfirmed. Compare both on a free VIN preview before you pay.
- Federal title data for the public
- Each seller is named on the Justice Department's public roster
- VinAudit price, per its home page
- 9.99 dollars for one report, bundles of five and ten
- EpicVIN price
- Not confirmed: its site would not open
- Refunds at VinAudit
- No refund after one report is delivered
What we could read, and what we could not
A fair comparison needs both sellers' own words, and we only got one set. The Justice Department's provider page and consumer page opened, and so did four VinAudit pages: its home page with the FAQ, its terms, its data sources and its report sections. EpicVIN's site answered every request, including one from the browser pane, with a Cloudflare block page. We did not work around it.
That shapes everything below. Where a fact comes from a page we read, we say so. Where EpicVIN is concerned, we report only what the government lists about it and leave price, layout and refund rules for you to read on its own order page before you enter a card.
The two sellers side by side
| Question | EpicVIN | VinAudit |
|---|---|---|
| Listed for public customers by the Justice Department | Yes | Yes |
| Other sites it owns that sell reports | VinGurus.com and Vininspect.com | Four more: VinCheck.Info, Vindata.com, VinReport, Vinsmart.com |
| Price for one report | Not confirmed | 9.99 dollars on its home page |
| Bundles | Not confirmed | Five for 19.99 dollars, ten for 29.99 dollars |
| Refund after delivery | Not confirmed | Non-refundable for a one-time purchase |
| Free step before paying | Not confirmed | A free summary of records found for the VIN |
The government page sorts providers alphabetically and says it favors none. A listing tells you a seller may resell the federal feed. It does not tell you whose report is better.
Why the title records should look alike
Behind both sellers sits NMVTIS, the federal title database fed by state title offices, auto recyclers, scrap and salvage lots and insurers. The Justice Department describes what a lookup returns: the title, the newest odometer figure, any brands, and for some cars a theft entry.
A brand is a state's label for a car's current or past condition: junk, salvage, flood and similar. If a car was branded in a reporting state, either seller should be able to pull that same entry. So a difference between two reports on one VIN usually points to the extras each company adds around the federal core, or to timing, because states send updates at different speeds.
What VinAudit says its report adds
VinAudit's pages describe more than the federal feed alone. Its data page names the National Insurance Crime Bureau, NHTSA and the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration as partners, plus state agencies for accident details and lenders for open liens. The home page lists six checks it runs:
- title history across registrations and states
- active theft status
- salvage and rebuild records from junk yards and auctions
- title problems such as odometer or flood brands
- past sale listings with dates and prices
- open liens
Its data page also says it covers more than 60 possible title brands and marks accident and sale records with an asterisk, a note that those two are not complete for every vehicle.

Money and terms you can check before paying
VinAudit's home page FAQ puts one report at 9.99 dollars, five at 19.99 dollars and ten at 29.99 dollars, and adds that current bundles show up once records are retrieved and ready to buy. The checkout screen has the last say.
Read the plan type at checkout
VinAudit's terms describe two ways to buy. Paying once buys one report, and the fee stays gone after delivery. A subscription bills monthly, renews until you cancel, and charges extra for each report. Confirm which one the order form is selling you. For EpicVIN, find the same wording on its own pages, since we could not.
What neither report can promise
VinAudit's own disclaimer is blunt, and it covers every seller using this system. The database holds no itemized repair record, and a few states do not feed it yet. Past damage can be missing when no insurer called the car a total loss and no state branded the title. VinAudit also says it does not guarantee a report is accurate or complete.
- A clean report means no record reached the database, not that the car was never hurt.
- Owner names are normally withheld under privacy law.
- Mechanical condition needs a mechanic; VinAudit's disclaimer itself tells buyers to get an independent inspection as well.
A practical way to choose
- Photograph the VIN plate on the car and confirm it equals the number in the ad.
- Run a free preview first and see whether any records exist for that number.
- Open each seller's order page and read the price, the plan type and the refund wording side by side.
- Buy one report, not a bundle, unless you are truly comparing several cars.
- Set anything alarming against the paper title the seller hands you.
If one report shows a brand and the other does not, do not average them. Treat the brand as real until the seller or the state's title office explains it.

Where VINReportLookup fits
VINReportLookup offers a third route that charges once. Type in the VIN, look over the free preview of what turned up, then choose one report or a pack. No renewal follows. The pricing page lists today's amounts, and a sample report shows the layout before you commit.
Look at the preview at no charge, then pay once for the report on the single car you are close to buying, whichever seller you favor.
Where this information comes from
- Bureau of Justice Assistance: approved NMVTIS data providers — Where EpicVIN and VinAudit are each listed, and the sites each owns.
- Bureau of Justice Assistance: NMVTIS for consumers — What the federal system holds and who reports into it.
- VinAudit: home page and FAQ — Listed price, bundles, the preview step and the six checks.
- VinAudit: terms and conditions — One-time versus subscription billing, refund wording and the NMVTIS disclaimer.
- VinAudit: data sources — Named partners and record types, with the asterisk note.
Sources and photos: Facts checked against the sources above in November 2026. Photos by Owen Michael Grech, Wesley Tingey and Patrick von der Wehd on Unsplash; diagrams by VINReportLookup.
Keep reading
- Carfax vs EpicVIN: a six-check list for choosing the report to buyThe same question for EpicVIN against the best-known report.
- Carfax vs VinAudit: six steps to pick the report you pay forHow VinAudit stands against Carfax on title access and price.
- VinAudit alternatives: what else you can buy, and what each report holdsOther ways to buy a history report if VinAudit does not fit.
- PricingWhat one report and each pack cost here once the preview has run.
Frequently asked questions
Is EpicVIN or VinAudit more accurate?
We could not rank them. The Justice Department lists both as approved to sell federal title data to the public, and it states no preference. EpicVIN's site would not open, and VinAudit says plainly that it does not guarantee its reports are accurate or complete. Compare the two on a single VIN.
Does VinAudit offer refunds?
Per its terms, a single-report purchase cannot be refunded after delivery, while a subscription renews every month until you cancel. Check which of the two the order form sells you, and keep a screenshot of the terms.
How much does VinAudit cost?
Its home page FAQ lists 9.99 dollars for one report, 19.99 dollars for five and 29.99 dollars for ten. The page also says current prices show when records are ready for purchase, so the checkout screen is the figure that counts.
Can I buy both reports on one car?
You can, but the title portion comes from the same federal system, so expect overlap. A second report earns its cost only if the first showed something odd you want confirmed, or if the car is expensive enough to justify the spend.
Do these reports replace a pre-purchase inspection?
No. VinAudit's own terms tell buyers to get an independent inspection as well, since hidden damage may never have been recorded anywhere. Run the VIN check first, then book a shop to examine the car.
Now check the car itself
The guide explains what to look for. The report shows what this VIN has on record.