
THE SHORT ANSWER
Both companies appear on the Justice Department's approved list, so either can supply the federal title and salvage record. carVertical publishes its prices, a return rule for empty reports and its report life, and we read them. EpicVIN's pages blocked us, so we cannot quote its price or terms. Before paying either, read the current price and refund rule on the checkout page itself.
- Federal listing
- Both names appear on the DOJ approved NMVTIS provider list
- carVertical single report
- $34.99 when we read the page; packs cost less per report
- carVertical empty report
- A report that finds no data is returned
- EpicVIN price and terms
- Not confirmed: its site refused automated reading
Start with what the two have in common
A used-car buyer comparing report sellers usually wants to know whether either one is a fly-by-night shop. The checkable answer sits on a government page. Both Carvertical.com and EpicVin.com sit on the federal approved-provider roster that the DOJ publishes for NMVTIS, under the heading for sellers open to everyone, consumers included.
The same page is where the two differ in a small way. The roster ties EpicVin.com to a pair of sibling storefronts, VinGurus.com and Vininspect.com, while carVertical appears with none. Shop around and two of those three names could mean paying twice for one provider's data.
What the listing does and does not say
What it confirms is permission to resell NMVTIS data. Price, the quality of any extras, support and refunds are outside its scope, so the rest of this page works on those.
What the federal part of either report can show
Because both sit on the approved list, the title layer should rest on the same national system. According to the DOJ's consumer guidance, a search can surface what the current title says, the brands it has carried, the latest mileage reading it holds, any insurer ruling of salvage or total loss, and word that the vehicle went to a recycler or scrapyard.
- Once a state applies a brand like junk, salvage or flood, it stays on the national record.
- The official report is intentionally short, built around five indicators tied to fraud and theft.
- Every state applies its own brand rules, so a wreck branded salvage in Ohio can stay clean on paper across the border.
That last point matters more than the choice between the two companies. The department itself advises reading up on those state differences before trusting any history report. Coverage is also incomplete: DOJ puts the share of US vehicles in the system at 87 percent, and no seller can fill that gap.

What carVertical says it adds
carVertical's US site describes scanning more than 1000 data sources across 48 countries, drawing on insurers, police and registration bodies, plus state registries, repair shops and connected-vehicle fleets. Its home page promises checks for damage, rolled-back odometers, factory equipment, market value, title problems, crash-test ratings and disaster exposure. It says a report is ready roughly 40 seconds after payment.
Treat the headline statistics with care. One page on the site claims roughly a quarter of US cars it checks have a damage record; another claims more than 4 in 10. Both are marketing claims on the same site, and neither tells you what your particular car will show.
The foreign-registry angle is the practical selling point. A car that spent time outside the country may have records that a purely domestic title search never touches. For a car that has lived in one state its whole life, that extra reach is worth less.
What the prices looked like when we read them
| Option | carVertical on the day we read it | EpicVIN |
|---|---|---|
| 1 report | $34.99 | Not confirmed |
| 2 reports | $24.99 each, $49.98 in total | Not confirmed |
| 3 reports | $19.99 each, $59.97 in total | Not confirmed |
carVertical's page shows crossed-out higher totals beside the bundles, a sign that the figures move with promotions. Read it again at checkout. For EpicVIN we have no number to print: its site answered our request with a security check page instead of its price list, and we did not try to get around that.
The bundle structure is the useful detail. A buyer weighing three listings pays less per car in a pack, which only pays off if you actually run all three.
What we could not confirm about EpicVIN
Opening epicvin.com, both with a plain command-line request and in a browser window, returned a Cloudflare page headed Attention Required and an HTTP 403 status. We did not complete the check or look for a copy elsewhere. That leaves its price, the exact list of report sections, any refund rule and its cancellation terms unread.
No claims either way
We have no sourced basis to call EpicVIN a scam, and none to vouch for its extras. The only firm fact we hold is its place on the government's approved list. Judge the rest from its checkout page, and screenshot the price and refund wording before you pay.
Refunds, report life and payment on the carVertical side
Here carVertical is easier to pin down. Its pricing page promises that a report which finds no data is returned immediately, so you do not lose the credit. Unspent reports stay valid for 6 months from purchase, and a finished report remains available for 30 days before it expires, so download the PDF if you want a keepsake.
- Payment: credit cards and PayPal.
- Legal weight: the company says its report is not evidence in court and suggests ordering before you sign the purchase agreement.
- Why it is not free: each request to its data sources costs the company money.
Those are the terms to compare against whatever EpicVIN shows at checkout: what happens to an empty report, how long unused credits last, and how long you can reopen a report.
Matching the report to the car on your list
- A car that came from overseas or has an odd ownership trail: carVertical's international sources are the reason to pick it.
- A plain domestic car from a nearby seller: the federal title record is the core, and both companies hold approval to sell it.
- Several cars on a shortlist: a bundle lowers the per-car cost, but only the figure on the live page counts.
- Anyone who wants a refund rule in writing before paying: carVertical states one, and EpicVIN's must be read at its checkout.
No report sees damage that was never filed with an insurer, a shop or a state. A clean result narrows the risk and leaves the mechanic's inspection as the next step.

Another route: preview first, then one payment
If you would rather see what a record holds before choosing a seller, type the VIN into this site and read the preview, which costs nothing. Past the preview you pay once per report, or buy a 3, 5 or 10 pack while shortlisting; nothing is billed monthly. Rates sit on the pricing page.
Whichever seller you pick, compare the number on the car's dash plate with the one in the advert before ordering. If they differ, walk away before paying.
Where this information comes from
- DOJ NMVTIS roster of approved data providers — the roster where we found both names and EpicVIN's two sibling sites
- DOJ NMVTIS guidance for consumers — what a federal title search covers and how states differ
- carVertical: Vehicle report pricing — bundle prices, empty-report return, payment methods
- carVertical: US home page — data source claims, report life and validity of unspent reports
Sources and photos: Facts checked against the sources above in November 2026. Photos by Dylan Michaud, Nina Mercado and Annika Wischnewsky on Unsplash; diagrams by VINReportLookup.
Keep reading
- carVertical alternatives: other VIN reports, what they cost, what they showother report sellers to weigh against carVertical
- EpicVIN alternatives: other VIN report sellers and how they chargeoptions if EpicVIN's terms do not suit you
- Carfax vs EpicVIN: a six-check list for choosing the report to buyhow EpicVIN stacks up against the best-known name
- Vehicle history report providers: who sells VIN reports and how they differwho actually supplies the data behind these reports
Frequently asked questions
Is carVertical or EpicVIN legit?
Both names appear on the Justice Department's approved NMVTIS provider list, which is the checkable credential. That confirms clearance to sell NMVTIS reports to the public. It does not rate their support or refunds, and we found nothing sourced to call either one a scam.
Which is cheaper, carVertical or EpicVIN?
We can only price one side. carVertical listed $34.99 for a single report and $19.99 each in a pack of 3 when we read it. EpicVIN's site blocked us, so we have no number. Compare the live checkout prices of both on the same day.
Can I get my money back from carVertical?
Its pricing page says a report that finds no data is returned right away. We did not read a wider refund policy, so for any other complaint, contact its customer service and keep your order email.
How long does a carVertical report last?
A generated report stays open for 30 days, then expires, and the company suggests saving a PDF. Reports you bought but did not use remain valid for 6 months from the purchase date.
Do these reports replace an inspection?
No. Both rest on records that someone filed, so damage that never reached an insurer, shop or state office will not appear. Use the report to screen the car and a mechanic to judge its condition.
Now check the car itself
The guide explains what to look for. The report shows what this VIN has on record.